Crab Cakes and Chardonnay: Brown Butter Meets Its Match

Crab Cakes and Chardonnay: Brown Butter Meets Its Match

There is a sound a crab cake makes when it meets hot fat: a soft, steady sizzle. Two minutes without touching it, and the underside turns deep gold. Then comes the butter, foaming and turning the color of hazelnuts, and a squeeze of lemon that makes it sing.

Maryland-style crab cakes are mostly crab: sweet lump meat held together with egg, a spoonful of mayonnaise, Dijon, and a little Old Bay, with almost no filler. This version builds on Mike’s Signature Crab Cakes from Michael Silverstein’s New Keto Cooking, with lemon zest and chives in the mix, a gentler hand on the spice, and a pan of lemon brown butter to finish.

The dish comes from the other side of the world, but the logic is the one Margaret River follows on its own coast: seafood, butter, and a white wine with enough body to meet them.

 

What Actually Matters Here

This pairing works at three points of contact. Weight meets weight. Nutty meets nutty. Lemon meets acid. You do not need to remember all three. You only need to taste them.

 

Three Points of Contact

Weight Meets Weight

Crab cakes made this way are rich: sweet crab, egg, and mayonnaise, seared in bacon fat and butter. A light, sharp white wine can feel thin beside them. Margaret River Chardonnay, with its medium-full body and creamy texture, meets the crab cakes at their own weight.

Nutty Meets Nutty

Brown butter is butter cooked until its milk solids toast, giving a deep, nutty aroma, hazelnut and caramel. Chardonnay aged in oak and on its lees carries its own nutty notes: cashew, hazelnut, toast. The butter and the wine speak the same language, and each makes the other taste richer.

Lemon Meets Acid

Lemon cuts through the butter and lifts the sweetness of the crab, and there is lemon zest in the mix as well. A wine without acidity would taste flat and flabby beside it. Margaret River Chardonnay’s fine, bright acidity meets the lemon rather than losing to it. It is the same rule we followed with tomato and Sangiovese in Week 33: acid in the food asks for acid in the glass.

This is where I think people overcomplicate things. They assume crab needs the leanest, most mineral white wine available. With plain, chilled crab legs, it often does. With a seared crust and brown butter, a Chardonnay with some body and texture is often the better choice.

This is the kind of shift that is easier to understand when you experience it, not just read about it. That is exactly what we explore at the Table.

Small icon of a pale yellow circle with a bottle of wine having a star bursting forth, suggesting a new aha sensory moment.

SENSORY PAUSE

Take a bite of crab cake without the sauce, then sip. Take a second bite with brown butter and lemon, and sip again. Notice what the brown butter does to the wine. Does it bring out the nutty notes, or the fruit?

 

The Art of Brown Butter

Brown butter asks for attention. Melt the butter over medium heat and let it foam. Swirl the pan and watch the milk solids at the bottom turn from pale to golden to deep hazelnut brown. The aroma will change from sweet to nutty. The moment it smells toasty, take it off the heat and add the lemon. A few seconds too long, and it tips into bitterness.

That transformation, from simple butter to something nutty and complex, is a small lesson in how heat builds flavor. Oak and time do something similar to Chardonnay.

 

The Golden Crust

The crust forms in bacon fat and butter: salt, a little smoke, and the toasty edge of a good sear. It is one of the best parts of the dish. Margaret River Chardonnay often carries a faint flinty, struck-match note and a touch of toast from the barrel, and the crust finds both. The wine’s acidity then resets the palate, so each bite tastes as bright as the first.

 

Why Not a Big, Oaky Chardonnay?

Heavily oaked Chardonnay, with lots of vanilla and butter, can overwhelm the delicate sweetness of the crab and make the dish feel heavy. The best match is a Chardonnay with measured oak, real acidity, and texture, which is exactly what Margaret River does so well.

 

If You Cannot Find Margaret River Chardonnay

  • White Burgundy from the Côte de Beaune: nutty, textured, a natural partner for brown butter.
  • Chablis: leaner and more mineral, lovely if you go light on the butter.
  • Margaret River Sémillon and Sauvignon Blanc blend: bright, herbal, and made for the same coast.
  • Chenin Blanc from the Loire: round and textural, with fine acid.

 

A Word on the Spice

Old Bay is part of what makes a crab cake taste like Maryland, but its celery salt and cayenne are loud. Heat makes a white wine taste warmer and thinner than it is. This version uses a little less than the original recipe: enough to taste, not enough to cover the crab or the fruit in the glass. If you like more spice, put a pinch on the table rather than in the mix.

 

What to Serve Alongside

Keep the sides simple so the crab and the wine stay at the center: buttered sweet corn, a shaved fennel and lemon salad, or small roasted potatoes. Skip cocktail sauce, vinegary slaw, and anything heavily spiced; they pull the pairing off balance.

 

This Week’s Challenge

Make crab cakes, or pick up good ones from the seafood counter, and finish them with brown butter and lemon. Pour Chardonnay. Notice how the nuttiness of the butter finds the wine, and how the lemon keeps everything bright.

Recipe

 

Maryland-style crab cakes with a golden-brown crust, garnished with fresh herbs and served with a charred lemon half on a white plate.

Maryland-Style Crab Cakes with Lemon Brown Butter

Anne Kjellgren @ Food Wine and Flavor
Maryland-style crab cakes, mostly crab with almost no filler, seared golden and finished with lemon brown butter. Plus the wines that pair best.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Chilling Time 30 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 5 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Servings 3 as a main (6 to 7 cakes), or 6 as a starter

Ingredients
  

For the Crab Cakes

  • 1 lb lump crabmeat picked over for shell
  • 2 large eggs
  • 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
  • 2 teaspoons Old Bay Seasoning
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
  • Finely grated zest of 1 lemon
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped chives
  • 3 strips thick-cut bacon for its rendered fat (about 2 tablespoons)
  • 1 tablespoon unsalted butter for searing

For the Lemon Brown Butter

  • 4 tablespoons unsalted butter cubed
  • 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon chopped fresh tarragon or dill
  • 1 teaspoon chopped chives
  • Flaky salt to finish
  • Lemon wedges for serving

Instructions
 

  • Render the bacon. Cook the bacon in a large cast-iron skillet over medium heat until crisp, about 3 minutes per side. Lift it out (save it for another use) and leave the fat in the pan. Turn off the heat.
  • Mix gently. In a bowl, whisk the eggs, mayonnaise, Old Bay, Dijon, and lemon zest. Add the crab and chives and fold with a spatula just until combined, keeping as many whole lumps as you can.
  • Form and chill. Scoop the mixture with a 1/3-cup measure into 6 or 7 cakes, pressing each lightly into shape. Set them on a plate and refrigerate for 30 minutes so they hold together in the pan.
  • Sear. Add the tablespoon of butter to the bacon fat and heat over medium-high until it foams. Lay in the crab cakes, in batches if needed, and do not touch them for 2 minutes. Flip carefully and cook 2 to 3 minutes more, until both sides are deep golden. Drain briefly on paper towels.
  • Brown the butter. Wipe the skillet, or use a small saucepan. Melt the butter over medium heat. Let it foam, then swirl the pan until the milk solids turn golden brown and smell nutty, 2 to 4 minutes.
    Crab Cakes - brown butter
  • Add lemon. Take the pan off the heat and add the lemon juice (it will sputter), then the tarragon and chives.
    Crab Cakes - crab cake into pan
  • Serve. Spoon the lemon brown butter around and over the crab cakes. Finish with flaky salt and serve right away with lemon wedges.
    Crab Cakes - crab cake flipped golden

Notes

Notes

  • Keep the lumps. Fold, do not stir. The less you work the mixture, the more it tastes of crab.
  • Crab. Fresh or pasteurized lump crabmeat from the seafood counter both work. Pick through it gently for bits of shell.
  • Hot pan, no crowding. Cook in two batches if needed, so the pan stays hot.
  • Watch the butter. It moves from golden to burnt quickly. Remove it from the heat the moment it smells toasty and the flecks are hazelnut brown.
  • Chill before searing. With no breadcrumbs, the cakes are fragile. Thirty minutes in the refrigerator firms them so they turn cleanly.
  • Credit. Adapted from Mike’s Signature Crab Cakes in New Keto Cooking: Fresh Ideas for Delicious Low-Carb Meals at Home by Michael Silverstein. Changes: less Old Bay, lemon zest and chives in the mix, bacon fat with a little butter in the pan, a 30-minute chill, and lemon brown butter in place of the original rémoulade.
  • Sides. Buttered sweet corn or a shaved fennel and lemon salad keep the focus on the crab.
  • Low-carb as written. The original is a keto recipe, and these changes keep it that way.
Keyword crab cake recipe, crab cakes with little filler, how to make crab cakes, keto crab cakes, lemon brown butter sauce, low carb crab cakes, lump crab cakes, Maryland crab cakes, what wine with crab cakes
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!
READ NEXT IN THIS WEEK’S WINE PATH

Continue Exploring

If this resonated, you might also enjoy:

Chablis & Crab Legs: When the Wine and the Sea Find Each Other - Same seafood, same grape, a different place.

Butter, Lemon, and the Grape That Answers Both - Wiener schnitzel with butter and lemon. The crab cakes have the same butter-and-lemon plate, and the post shows how acidity handles richness.

Mâcon & Spring Fish: A Pairing for the Season - Chardonnay with fish, from the Burgundy side.

Warm Artichoke & Burrata Plate with California Chardonnay - Warm artichoke and burrata show how a California bottle handles richness, and it sets up what the crab cakes will ask of a Margaret River Chardonnay.

 

Last Updated:

Post Created:  Nov 5, 2026

Margaret River Chardonnay: The Pendulum Finds Its Center

Margaret River Chardonnay: The Pendulum Finds Its Center

For a while, Australian Chardonnay had a reputation. In the 1980s and 1990s, it was big, golden, and heavily oaked, with ripe tropical fruit and a thick layer of butter and vanilla. The world loved it, and then, quite suddenly, the world grew tired of it.

What happened next is one of the most interesting stories in modern wine, and Margaret River sits right at the center of it.

 

What Actually Matters Here

Chardonnay is a mirror. It reflects its place and its winemaker more clearly than almost any other grape. Margaret River Chardonnay is what happens when a moderate climate meets winemakers who have discovered, over decades, when to step in and when to step back. The result is generous but restrained, rich but fresh.

 

The Pendulum

After the era of big, oaky Chardonnay, many Australian winemakers swung hard the other way. They picked earlier, used less oak, and blocked the buttery second fermentation. Some wines became lean and sharp, almost austere. It was a correction, and like most corrections, it went a little too far.

Over the past two decades, the pendulum has settled. The best Margaret River Chardonnays now have ripe stone fruit and citrus, measured oak, fine acidity, and a savoury, textural depth. They are neither heavy nor thin. They are balanced.

We explored this same tension with California Chardonnay, restraint versus intervention. Margaret River shows what it looks like when the answer is a thoughtful yes to both.

 

What It Tastes Like

Margaret River Chardonnay usually leads with white peach, nectarine, and grapefruit, sometimes lemon and fig. Around the fruit you may find cashew, hazelnut, and toast from oak and lees, and often a faint struck-match or flinty note. The acidity is bright and fine, and the finish is long and often a little saline.

On the palate, it tends to be medium to full in body, with a creamy but not heavy texture.

Small icon of a pale yellow circle with a bottle of wine having a star bursting forth, suggesting a new aha sensory moment.SENSORY PAUSE

Take a sip and hold it for a moment before swallowing. Notice the texture first, then the flavor. Is it creamy, silky, or crisp? Then notice the finish. Does it fade, or does it linger with a hint of salt?

 

The Hens and Chicks

Much of Margaret River’s Chardonnay comes from a particular vine selection, known locally as the Gingin clone. Its bunches carry berries of very different sizes, some full-sized, some tiny, a pattern growers call hens and chicks. The small berries have a high ratio of skin to juice, which concentrates flavor and gives the wine extra intensity and texture.

It is a small detail with a large effect, and a good reminder that wine is shaped in the vineyard long before it reaches the cellar.

 

Old World and New World

Chardonnay’s Old World home is Burgundy, where it makes everything from the steely, oyster-shell Chablis we paired with crab legs to rich, nutty wines from the Côte de Beaune. White Burgundy tends to be more restrained, with more earth and mineral and less fruit.

Margaret River Chardonnay has more sunshine in its fruit: riper peach, brighter citrus. But it shares Burgundy’s interest in texture, acidity, and restraint. It is New World in its generosity and Old World in its manners.

A pattern I keep seeing is that people talk about Chardonnay as one flavor. Taste a Chablis, a California Chardonnay, and a Margaret River Chardonnay side by side, and you will find three distinct personalities from one grape.

 

A Grape With a Long Family Tree

Chardonnay was born in Burgundy, the child of Pinot Noir’s family and an old, humble grape called Gouais Blanc. Today it grows almost everywhere wine is made, from England to Chile. Few grapes adapt so willingly, and few reveal so honestly where they have been planted.

 

How It Is Made

Most fine Margaret River Chardonnay is fermented in oak barrels rather than steel tanks. Barrel fermentation integrates the oak more gently than aging alone, adding texture as much as flavor. Many winemakers also leave the wine on its lees for several months, sometimes stirring them, which builds a creamy, savoury depth.

Whether to allow the buttery second fermentation is a key decision. Many Margaret River winemakers allow only part of it, or none, to keep the wine’s fresh acidity and let the fruit and texture lead. The goal is richness without heaviness.

 

How It Ages

Good Margaret River Chardonnay ages well. Over five to ten years, the fruit softens toward baked apple and dried fig, the nutty notes deepen, and the texture becomes silkier. Its fine acidity keeps it fresh along the way. Most bottles are delicious young, but a few years of patience can reward you.

 

Where to Start

  • Everyday ($): A regional Margaret River Chardonnay with light oak. White peach, citrus, a touch of cashew. Fresh and easy.
  • Better ($$): A Chardonnay from the cooler south around Karridale. Tighter citrus, finer acidity, a hint of flint.
  • Luxury ($$$): A top single-vineyard Chardonnay from the northern gravels. Layered, textural, long, and able to age for a decade or more.

 

Serving It

Serve Margaret River Chardonnay lightly chilled, around 50 to 55 degrees Fahrenheit. Too cold and its texture and nutty notes disappear. Pour it into a glass with a generous bowl so the aromas can gather. Fuller examples open beautifully over half an hour.

 

At the Table

Margaret River Chardonnay loves seafood with a little richness: pan-seared fish, scallops, lobster, crab, roast chicken, or dishes finished with butter. Thursday, we pair it with crab cakes and lemon brown butter.

 

This Week’s Challenge

If you can, taste a Margaret River Chardonnay beside a white Burgundy or a Chablis. Use Monday’s four sources on each. Notice which note is loudest in each, and which wine tastes more of fruit, and which more of place.

 

READ NEXT IN THIS WEEK’S WINE PATH

 

Continue Exploring

If this resonated, you might also enjoy:

Chardonnay: The Foundation Grape, and Why Chablis Is Only the Beginning. Chablis is the starting point most people never leave. This piece shows why it matters as a reference point, and what changes once the grape moves somewhere warmer.

Chardonnay’s Full Range: From Chablis to Côte de Beaune. One grape, many expressions. Follow it across a single region to hear how much a site and a winemaker can change in the glass.

Chardonnay: The Three Decisions That Explain Everything. Oak, malolactic fermentation, and lees are the choices behind most of what you taste. Learn to read them once, and every Chardonnay becomes easier to read.

Muscadet: The Misunderstood White Wine Worth Discovering. A wine that rests on its lees and still feels light. It shows that texture doesn’t always need oak or butter to arrive.

Sauvignon Blanc: The Grape That Travels. A grape that moves easily between climates and styles. It’s a useful counterpoint for anyone wondering how place shapes a white wine.

 

Last Updated:

Post Created: Nov 3, 2026

Where the Richness Comes From: A Practice for Chardonnay

Where the Richness Comes From: A Practice for Chardonnay

People say they love Chardonnay, or they say they cannot stand it. Very often they are describing the same thing: a rich, buttery, toasty style that is not really about the grape at all. It is about what happened to the grape after it was picked.

Chardonnay shows every decision made in the cellar. Once you can taste those decisions, you can choose the Chardonnay you actually want.

What Actually Matters Here

The richness in a Chardonnay can come from four places: the fruit itself, the oak barrel, a second fermentation that softens acid, and time spent resting on the lees. Each leaves its own signature. Telling them apart takes attention, nothing more.

The Practice: Four Sources, One Glass

Pour a Chardonnay and taste it slowly, looking for four things, one at a time.

  • The fruit: citrus, green apple, pear, white peach, or tropical notes. This is the grape and the climate speaking.
  • The barrel: vanilla, toast, baking spice, a little smoke. This is oak.
  • The butter: a soft, creamy note, sometimes like custard. This is a second fermentation at work.
  • The bread: toasted nuts, brioche, a savory, doughy depth. This is time on the lees.

You will not find all four in every wine. The point is to notice which ones are there, and which one is loudest.

The Fruit

Cool places give Chardonnay lean citrus and green apple. Warmer places give it stone fruit, melon, and tropical fruit. In Margaret River, you will often find white peach and grapefruit, a sign of a moderate climate.

The Barrel

Oak adds vanilla, toast, and spice, most of all when the barrels are new. Older barrels add texture with little flavor. Wine aged in steel shows no oak at all, which is why an unoaked Chardonnay can taste so clear.

The Butter

Many Chardonnays go through a second fermentation that softens sharp malic acid into rounder lactic acid. The result can be a buttery aroma and a fuller texture. The full mechanics are in Chardonnay: The Three Decisions That Explain Everything. At the glass, the question is simply whether the butter is there, and how loud it is.

The Bread

When wine rests on its lees, the spent yeast left after fermentation, it gains nutty, bready notes and a creamier texture. Some winemakers stir the lees to deepen the effect. We met the same idea in Week 42, in traditional-method sparkling wine.

Small icon of a pale yellow circle with a bottle of wine having a star bursting forth, suggesting a new aha sensory moment.SENSORY PAUSE 

 

Hold a toasted hazelnut and a lemon wedge near the glass. Smell the lemon, then the wine. Then the hazelnut, then the wine. Notice which one the wine leans toward. That is where its richness comes from.

 

Color as a Clue

Before you taste, look. We've practiced reading the rim of a red wine. White wine gives clues too. A pale, lemon-green Chardonnay is often young and unoaked. A deeper gold can suggest oak, riper fruit, or age. Color will not tell you everything, but it can tell you what to look for first.

 

Temperature Changes What You Taste

Serve a Chardonnay too cold and its fruit and nutty notes go quiet; only the acid comes through. Let it warm a few degrees in the glass and the texture opens, the oak and lees become easier to find, and the fruit fills in. Taste the same glass cold and then ten minutes later, and you will notice the difference.

 

A Fifth Note: The Struck Match

Some modern Chardonnays, including many from Margaret River, carry a faint smoky, flinty aroma, like a match just struck. It comes from a winemaking style that limits oxygen during fermentation. In small doses it adds tension and complexity. It is a clue that the winemaker was aiming for precision rather than plushness.

 

Why This Matters

Once you know the sources, you can also read a wine list or a back label differently. Words like barrel-fermented, lees-aged, or unoaked stop being jargon and start telling you what the wine will feel like in your mouth.

A pattern I keep seeing is that people decide they dislike Chardonnay after one heavily oaked, buttery glass. What they dislike is a style, not a grape. Once you can taste where the richness comes from, you can ask for what you want: less oak, no butter, more citrus, more texture.

 

Why This Is Practice, Not Performance

No one needs to announce malolactic fermentation at dinner. The value is in the noticing. Separating a wine into its sources slows you down and lets you taste what is there, rather than what you expected Chardonnay to be.

The first time, the wine will simply taste rich. By the third bottle, you will know why, and you will know what to reach for: which Chardonnay for a quiet evening alone, which for buttery crab cakes, which for a crowd.

This Week’s Challenge

Taste two Chardonnays side by side this week: one unoaked, one oaked. Use the four sources on each. Write down which note is loudest in each wine. You will have your own small map of what Chardonnay can be.

 

READ NEXT IN THIS WEEK’S WINE PATH        

 

Continue Exploring

If this resonated, you might also enjoy:

California Chardonnay: What the New World Did with a French Grape - a second look at how winemaking shapes the richness

Feel the Mousse: A Practice for Sparkling Wine - the lees and bubbles side of the same richness

 

Last Updated:

Post Created: Nov 2, 2026

Margaret River: A Wine Region Between Two Oceans

Margaret River: A Wine Region Between Two Oceans

Margaret River: A Wine Region Between Two Oceans

In the far southwest corner of Australia, a narrow cape of land reaches out into the sea. To the west is the Indian Ocean. To the south, the Southern Ocean. Between them lies a strip of tall forest, surf beaches, and vineyards, about a hundred kilometers long and barely a few dozen wide.

Map of Australia in grey with the South West Australia region highlighted in teal along the southwestern coast, and a gold map pin marking Margaret River near the southern tip of that region.

This is Margaret River. It is one of the youngest fine wine regions in the world, and one of the most quietly confident.

What Actually Matters Here

Margaret River is defined by the ocean on nearly every side. The water keeps the climate mild and remarkably even: warm, dry summers without extreme heat, and gentle, wet winters. That steadiness lets grapes ripen slowly and evenly, year after year, which gives the wines a rare combination of ripe fruit, fresh acidity, and consistency.

Here’s what I’m noticing: people expect Australian wine to be big and sun-baked. Margaret River wine is the opposite of that stereotype. It is poised, balanced, and precise, closer in spirit to a coastal European wine than to anything hot and heavy.

A Region Built on a Report

Most great wine regions grew slowly over centuries. Margaret River began with a piece of research. In the mid-1960s, an agricultural scientist studied the area’s climate and concluded that it closely resembled Bordeaux, with an even more reliable pattern of rainfall and warmth. He suggested it could produce outstanding wine.

A small group of local doctors took the idea seriously. In the late 1960s they planted the first commercial vineyards, often as a passion project alongside their medical practices. Within a few decades, the region was producing some of Australia’s most celebrated wines.

Two Oceans and a Warm Current

Just offshore runs the Leeuwin Current, an unusual current of warm water flowing south along the Western Australian coast. It keeps winters mild and helps prevent frost. Sea breezes cool the vineyards on summer afternoons. The result is one of the most moderate climates in the wine world, with small differences between day and night and between one year and the next.

That evenness is rare, and it shows in the glass. Margaret River wines tend to taste settled, with fruit and acid in balance rather than in competition.

Small icon of a pale yellow circle with a bottle of wine having a star bursting forth, suggesting a new aha sensory moment.

SENSORY PAUSE

Pour a glass of Margaret River Chardonnay and taste it slowly. Notice how the fruit and the freshness arrive together, neither pushing ahead of the other. That sense of balance is the climate, translated into a single sip.

 

Ancient Ground

Beneath the vineyards lie some of the oldest soils on earth: gravelly, sandy loams over weathered granite, with ironstone gravels scattered through them. These soils drain well and hold little fertility, which keeps the vines from growing too vigorously. The grapes stay small and concentrated.

Around the vineyards, tall karri and marri forests grow, and kangaroos graze between the rows at dusk. Many growers net their vines against flocks of small birds that arrive at harvest. It is a wild, green, coastal place, and the vineyards feel stitched into it rather than laid over it.

Why Steadiness Matters

In many wine regions, the character of the wine swings from year to year. A cold spring, a heat wave, a rainy harvest, and the wine changes. Margaret River’s climate is so even that those swings are unusually small. Growers can plan with confidence, and wine lovers can expect a certain style from vintage to vintage.

It is not that every year tastes the same. It is that the region rarely has a bad one. For a young wine region, that reliability helped build a reputation quickly.

Surf, Forest, and Small Towns

Margaret River is also a coastal community with a strong outdoor culture. Its beaches draw surfers from around the world, and the towns are small, relaxed, and close to the forest. Wineries sit alongside galleries, cheese makers, and farm kitchens. Food and wine here feel less like a luxury and more like part of daily life on the coast.

The Places Inside the Place

Margaret River runs north to south, and it changes as it goes.

Wilyabrup and the North

The heart of the region’s early plantings, slightly warmer, with deep gravelly soils. Known especially for powerful, structured Cabernet Sauvignon and rich, layered Chardonnay.

Wallcliffe and the Center

Around the town of Margaret River itself, with a strong ocean influence and a balance of warmth and freshness.

Karridale and the South

Cooler and wetter, closer to the Southern Ocean, among tall karri forest. Chardonnay from here tends toward tension, citrus, and fine acidity.

Map of the Margaret River wine region, a narrow strip of coast divided into three subregions from north to south: Wilyabrup and the North in pale gold, Wallcliffe and the Centre in medium gold, and Karridale and the South in deep gold.

What Grows Here

Margaret River is best known for two grapes. Cabernet Sauvignon makes elegant, structured reds, often compared to Bordeaux. Chardonnay makes some of the most admired white wines in Australia, generous and precise at once. The region is also known for fresh blends of Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon, bright and herbal, made for the coast.

What ties them together is freshness. Even the region’s richest wines keep a line of acidity running through them, the mark of a place where the ocean is never far away.

The Rhythm of the Year

Harvest here comes in the Southern Hemisphere late summer and early autumn, roughly February to April. Chardonnay is usually picked early in that window to keep its freshness; Cabernet Sauvignon comes in later. Birds and the occasional autumn rain are the main worries, and many vineyards are fully netted by harvest time.

An Old World and New World Conversation

We first met Chardonnay in its Old World home in Burgundy and Chablis, then in California, where the question was restraint versus intervention. Margaret River adds a third voice. It has the sunshine of the New World and something of the poise of Burgundy, and its winemakers have spent decades finding the balance between them.

Tuesday’s post follows that balance into the glass.

What to Pour

  • Everyday ($): A regional Margaret River Chardonnay with light oak. White peach, citrus, a touch of cashew, fresh finish. Easy with a weeknight seafood dinner.
  • Better ($$): Chardonnay from the cooler south around Karridale, or a single-site wine from the center. More citrus and tension, finer texture, a whisper of struck match.
  • Luxury ($$$): A top single-vineyard Chardonnay from the northern gravels around Wilyabrup. Layered stone fruit, toasted nuts, a long saline finish, built to age for a decade.

At the Table

This is a coastal region, and its wines are made for the sea: grilled fish, shellfish, and simple, beautifully cooked seafood. On Thursday, we pair Margaret River Chardonnay with Maryland-style crab cakes, seared golden and finished with lemon and nutty brown butter.

 

This Week’s Challenge

Find a Chardonnay from Margaret River and pour it slightly chilled, around 50 to 55 degrees Fahrenheit. Taste once cold, then again after ten minutes in the glass. Notice what opens as it warms: fruit, nuts, or something mineral.

Tell me what you noticed. Reply to this week’s email or leave a comment below. I read every one.

 

READ NEXT IN THIS WEEK’S WINE PATH      

 

Mushroom Risotto and Maipo Cabernet: When Time Softens the Grip

Mushroom Risotto and Maipo Cabernet: When Time Softens the Grip

Mushroom Risotto and Maipo Cabernet: When Time Softens the Grip

There is a point, late in October, when the evenings pull in and the kitchen becomes the warmest room in the house. That is when risotto makes sense. A pot on the stove, a ladle of hot stock, twenty minutes of slow stirring, and mushrooms browning in butter until the house smells like a forest floor.

Mushroom risotto is simple food done patiently. This week it meets a wine that has been waiting patiently too.

What Actually Matters Here

This pairing works at three points of contact. Earth meets earth. Time softens the grip. Herbs meet herbs. It also comes with one honest caution, which is worth understanding because it applies far beyond this plate.

The Honest Caution: Umami and Tannin

Mushrooms and Parmigiano are rich in umami, the savoury taste of glutamates. Umami has a curious effect on red wine: it makes tannin taste firmer and more bitter. A young, grippy Cabernet beside a bowl of mushrooms can turn harsh and metallic.

That is why the wine matters as much as the grape. A Maipo Cabernet with several years of age, its tannins already softened and smoothed, behaves very differently from a young one. The structure is still there, but it has relaxed enough to sit beside the umami rather than fight it.

Three Points of Contact

Earth Meets Earth

Browned mushrooms and dried porcini bring a deep, woodsy savour. An aged Cabernet carries its own: cedar, dried herbs, forest floor, a hint of leather. Like meets like, and each makes the other taste more like itself.

Time Softens the Grip

Bottle age softens Cabernet’s tannin, and the risotto does its part too. Butter and Parmigiano bring fat and salt, both of which soften the feel of tannin on the palate. Together they turn a potential clash into a conversation.

Herbs Meet Herbs

Thyme and parsley in the pot sit right beside Maipo’s mint and the green thread we practiced finding on Monday. A red without that herbal edge would feel heavier beside the herbs in the dish.

This is where I think people overcomplicate things. They hear that mushrooms and big reds clash and stop there. The real answer is about texture and time: give the tannin some age, give the dish some fat, and the pairing opens up.

This is the kind of shift that is easier to understand when you experience it, not just read about it. That is exactly what we explore at the Table.

Small icon of a pale yellow circle with a bottle of wine having a star bursting forth, suggesting a new aha sensory moment.

SENSORY PAUSE

Take a sip of the wine alone and notice the grip. Then take a bite of risotto with extra Parmigiano and sip again. Does the wine feel softer? Rounder? Now try a bite of mushroom with no cheese at all. Notice how much the fat and salt were doing.

 

Setting Up the Plate for Cabernet

  • Be generous with Parmigiano and finish with a little extra butter. Fat and salt are the tannin’s friends.
  • Brown the mushrooms well and add soaked dried porcini. Deeper, woodsier flavors meet an aged wine more fully.
  • Open the wine thirty minutes before dinner so it can relax further.
  • Serve it slightly cool, around 60 to 65 degrees Fahrenheit, so the alcohol stays in the background.

If Your Cabernet Is Young

If the only Cabernet on hand is young and firm, decant it for an hour and lean hard on the cheese and butter. Or choose a softer red for the risotto and save the young Cabernet for a steak.

A small handful of extra browned mushrooms on top, and a few shavings of aged Parmigiano, give even a firmer wine more to hold onto.

Other Reds That Work

  • Carménère: Chile’s softer Bordeaux grape, with gentle tannins and herbal notes, a natural match.
  • Pinot Noir: light, earthy, and a classic partner for mushrooms.
  • Merlot: soft and plummy, easy beside umami.
  • Nebbiolo from Langhe: the Italian mushroom red, as we saw in Week 32. Choose a softer, younger bottle.

Why Not Just Choose White?

Many people pour white wine with risotto, and a rich Chardonnay is lovely here. But mushroom risotto is earthy enough to welcome a red. The trick is choosing the red for its texture as much as its flavor.

A Word on Timing

Risotto waits for no one. It is best in the first few minutes, when it still flows gently across the plate. Open the wine before you start stirring, pour a glass for the cook, and have the table set before the rice is done.

This Week’s Challenge

Make mushroom risotto on a cool evening and pour a Cabernet with some age. Taste the wine before the first bite and after. Then try one bite with extra cheese and one without, and notice what the fat does to the grip.

Recipe

 

 

Mushroom risotto topped with shaved Parmesan cheese and fresh parsley, served on a blue plate with a fork.

Mushroom Risotto with Porcini and Parmigiano

Anne Kjellgren @ Food Wine and Flavor
Mushroom risotto is earthy and rich in umami, which can make young Cabernet taste harsh. Why an aged Maipo Cabernet works, and how to set up the plate.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 35 minutes
Soak the porcini 30 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 20 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine Italian
Servings 4 as a main, 6 as a starter

Ingredients
  

For the Mushrooms

  • 1 oz dried porcini
  • 1 1/2 cups hot water for soaking the porcini
  • 1 lb mixed fresh mushrooms cremini, shiitake, oyster, sliced
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 2 garlic cloves minced
  • 1 teaspoon fresh thyme leaves
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper

For the Risotto

  • 5 to 6 cups chicken or vegetable stock
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 2 shallots finely chopped
  • 1 1/2 cups Arborio or Carnaroli rice
  • 1/2 cup dry white wine
  • 2 tablespoons cold unsalted butter
  • 3/4 cup finely grated Parmigiano-Reggiano plus shavings to serve
  • 2 tablespoons chopped flat-leaf parsley

Instructions
 

  • Soak the porcini. Cover the dried porcini with the hot water and soak 30 minutes. Lift them out, squeeze gently, and chop. Strain the soaking liquid through a paper towel or fine sieve into the stock, leaving any grit behind. Keep the stock at a bare simmer.
    Mushroom Risotto - ingredients in bowls
  • Brown the fresh mushrooms. In the risotto pot, heat 1 tablespoon butter and the olive oil over medium-high heat. Add half the mushrooms in a single layer and cook without stirring for 2 to 3 minutes, until browned, then stir and cook 2 minutes more. Repeat with the rest. Add garlic, thyme, and the chopped porcini for the final minute; season and set aside.
    Mushroom Risotto - browned mushrooms in pan
  • Toast the rice. Lower the heat to medium. Add the 2 tablespoons olive oil and the shallots to the same pot and cook until soft, about 3 minutes. Add the rice and stir 2 minutes, until the grains are coated and the edges look translucent.
    Mushroom Risotto - rice toasting in pan
  • Add the wine. Pour in the white wine and stir until it is almost fully absorbed.
    Mushroom Risotto - first broth added to rice
  • Add the stock slowly. Add hot stock one ladle at a time, stirring often and waiting until most of it is absorbed before adding the next. Continue 18 to 22 minutes, until the rice is tender with a slight bite and the risotto is creamy and loose.
  • Finish. Stir in about two-thirds of the mushrooms. Off the heat, add the cold butter and grated Parmigiano and stir vigorously for 30 seconds. Add a final splash of stock if it seems stiff; it should flow. Season with salt and pepper.
  • Serve. Spoon into warm shallow bowls. Top with the remaining mushrooms, Parmigiano shavings, parsley, and cracked pepper. Serve at once.

Notes

Notes

  • Rice matters. Arborio is widely available; Carnaroli holds its shape a little better and makes an especially creamy risotto. Do not rinse the rice.
  • Keep the stock hot. Cold stock slows the cooking and makes the risotto gluey.
  • Brown in batches. Crowded mushrooms steam instead of browning, and the browned edges carry most of the flavor.
  • Vegetarian version. Use vegetable stock and a vegetarian hard cheese in place of Parmigiano-Reggiano, which is traditionally made with animal rennet.
  • Make ahead. Cook the risotto about three-quarters of the way, spread it on a sheet pan to cool, and refrigerate. Finish with hot stock, butter, and cheese just before serving.
  • Leftovers. Chilled leftover risotto makes excellent arancini or crisp risotto cakes.
Keyword autumn risotto, creamy mushroom risotto, easy mushroom risotto, how to make risotto, mushroom risotto recipe, porcini risotto, risotto with parmesan, vegetarian risotto, what wine with mushroom risotto
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

READ NEXT IN THIS WEEK’S WINE PATH