Where the Richness Comes From: A Practice for Chardonnay

by Anne Kjellgren @ Food Wine and Flavor | Nov 2, 2026 | Expand Your Palate, What Actually Matters

People say they love Chardonnay, or they say they cannot stand it. Very often they are describing the same thing: a rich, buttery, toasty style that is not really about the grape at all. It is about what happened to the grape after it was picked.

Chardonnay shows every decision made in the cellar. Once you can taste those decisions, you can choose the Chardonnay you actually want.

What Actually Matters Here

The richness in a Chardonnay can come from four places: the fruit itself, the oak barrel, a second fermentation that softens acid, and time spent resting on the lees. Each leaves its own signature. Telling them apart takes attention, nothing more.

The Practice: Four Sources, One Glass

Pour a Chardonnay and taste it slowly, looking for four things, one at a time.

  • The fruit: citrus, green apple, pear, white peach, or tropical notes. This is the grape and the climate speaking.
  • The barrel: vanilla, toast, baking spice, a little smoke. This is oak.
  • The butter: a soft, creamy note, sometimes like custard. This is a second fermentation at work.
  • The bread: toasted nuts, brioche, a savory, doughy depth. This is time on the lees.

You will not find all four in every wine. The point is to notice which ones are there, and which one is loudest.

The Fruit

Cool places give Chardonnay lean citrus and green apple. Warmer places give it stone fruit, melon, and tropical fruit. In Margaret River, you will often find white peach and grapefruit, a sign of a moderate climate.

The Barrel

Oak adds vanilla, toast, and spice, most of all when the barrels are new. Older barrels add texture with little flavor. Wine aged in steel shows no oak at all, which is why an unoaked Chardonnay can taste so clear.

The Butter

Many Chardonnays go through a second fermentation that softens sharp malic acid into rounder lactic acid. The result can be a buttery aroma and a fuller texture. The full mechanics are in Chardonnay: The Three Decisions That Explain Everything. At the glass, the question is simply whether the butter is there, and how loud it is.

The Bread

When wine rests on its lees, the spent yeast left after fermentation, it gains nutty, bready notes and a creamier texture. Some winemakers stir the lees to deepen the effect. We met the same idea in Week 42, in traditional-method sparkling wine.

SENSORY PAUSE 

 

Hold a toasted hazelnut and a lemon wedge near the glass. Smell the lemon, then the wine. Then the hazelnut, then the wine. Notice which one the wine leans toward. That is where its richness comes from.

 

Color as a Clue

Before you taste, look. We've practiced reading the rim of a red wine. White wine gives clues too. A pale, lemon-green Chardonnay is often young and unoaked. A deeper gold can suggest oak, riper fruit, or age. Color will not tell you everything, but it can tell you what to look for first.

 

Temperature Changes What You Taste

Serve a Chardonnay too cold and its fruit and nutty notes go quiet; only the acid comes through. Let it warm a few degrees in the glass and the texture opens, the oak and lees become easier to find, and the fruit fills in. Taste the same glass cold and then ten minutes later, and you will notice the difference.

 

A Fifth Note: The Struck Match

Some modern Chardonnays, including many from Margaret River, carry a faint smoky, flinty aroma, like a match just struck. It comes from a winemaking style that limits oxygen during fermentation. In small doses it adds tension and complexity. It is a clue that the winemaker was aiming for precision rather than plushness.

 

Why This Matters

Once you know the sources, you can also read a wine list or a back label differently. Words like barrel-fermented, lees-aged, or unoaked stop being jargon and start telling you what the wine will feel like in your mouth.

A pattern I keep seeing is that people decide they dislike Chardonnay after one heavily oaked, buttery glass. What they dislike is a style, not a grape. Once you can taste where the richness comes from, you can ask for what you want: less oak, no butter, more citrus, more texture.

 

Why This Is Practice, Not Performance

No one needs to announce malolactic fermentation at dinner. The value is in the noticing. Separating a wine into its sources slows you down and lets you taste what is there, rather than what you expected Chardonnay to be.

The first time, the wine will simply taste rich. By the third bottle, you will know why, and you will know what to reach for: which Chardonnay for a quiet evening alone, which for buttery crab cakes, which for a crowd.

This Week’s Challenge

Taste two Chardonnays side by side this week: one unoaked, one oaked. Use the four sources on each. Write down which note is loudest in each wine. You will have your own small map of what Chardonnay can be.

 

READ NEXT IN THIS WEEK’S WINE PATH        

 

Continue Exploring

If this resonated, you might also enjoy:

California Chardonnay: What the New World Did with a French Grape - a second look at how winemaking shapes the richness

Feel the Mousse: A Practice for Sparkling Wine - the lees and bubbles side of the same richness

 

Last Updated: Nov 2, 2026

Post Created: Nov 2, 2026

Rustic wood table with five small plates representing sweet, spicy, crunchy, creamy and salty.

You just read about how wine changes.

At the Table, you experience it.

We don’t try multiple wines.
We stay with one—and see what actually shifts.

That’s where it starts to click.

Receive the Weekly Practice

If you’d like to explore wine this way each week, I share guided tastings and seasonal reflections by email.

→ Expand Your Palate

Column Header for Comments which reads, "Questions?"

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *